Debunking Meta Horizon's "Competitive Rate in the Market"

Meta is testing monetization of fungible goods in Horizon, issuing 52.5% of each sale to the Creator. Meta's VP of Horizon told The Verge "We think it’s a pretty competitive rate in the market." What are the rates in the market? Here's the list:

Creators get...

28% from Roblox

52.5% from Meta Quest Store + Horizon Worlds

55% from YouTube

70% from PlayStation

70% from Microsoft Xbox

70% from Valve corporation up to $10M, then 75-80%

70% from Samsung Electronics Galaxy Store

80% from OnlyFans

80% from Apple App Store up to $1M, then 70%

80% from Amazon App Store up to $1M, then 70%

85% from Google Play Store up to $1M, then 70%

85% from Microsoft Store, ranging up to 88%

88% from Epic Games

88% from Patreon, ranging up to 95%

90% from Substack

95% from The Sandbox + re-investment into Creators

97.5% from Decentraland + secondary sale royalties + 2.5% re-invested into community DAO

97.5% from OpenSea + secondary sale royalties

98% from LooksRare + secondary sale royalties + staking

As for the ownership experience and lifetime value of Meta’s fungible goods, buyers...

  • cannot verify ownership of the goods they pay for
  • cannot take their virtual goods beyond the platform
  • cannot see how the market values their virtual goods
  • cannot resell their virtual goods for profit or scrap

What do you think?